Herald Square in the heart of Midtown Manhattan is one of New York City’s most iconic landmarks, bustling with energy and activity. For locals and tourists alike, it offers a wide variety of dining options that go beyond the usual fast food chains and coffee shops. Whether you’re craving a juicy burger or an indulgent milkshake, Herald Square has you covered. In this article, we’ll dive into the best spots for burgers to shakes in Herald Square, giving you a well-rounded guide to the area’s top eateries.

The Herald Square Food Scene

Herald Square has long been known for its shopping, home to the historic Macy’s department store, but its food scene has also grown into a culinary destination. With crowds drawn to the nearby Penn Station and Times Square, eateries here serve a range of quick bites and gourmet meals, making it a perfect spot for foodies on the go or those looking for a casual sit-down experience.

Let’s explore some of the standout places where you can indulge in the best burgers and shakes.

1. Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer

No list about burgers and shakes in Herald Square would be complete without mentioning Black Tap, one of NYC’s most famous burger joints. Known for its massive, Instagram-worthy milkshakes and gourmet burgers, Black Tap is a must-visit for anyone in the area.

Their burgers range from classic cheeseburgers to more extravagant options like the Truffle Burger, which features Wagyu beef, aged Gouda, and truffle aioli. On the shake side, you can’t go wrong with their Crazy Shakes, which include toppings like cotton candy, candy bars, and even whole slices of cake.

Black Tap provides a casual atmosphere with friendly service, making it perfect for both tourists and locals looking for that ultimate indulgence.

Pro Tip: Try to visit during off-peak hours to avoid the long lines, especially if you want a seat inside to savor both the burger and shake experience.

2. Shake Shack: A New York Staple

It’s impossible to discuss burgers in Herald Square without bringing up Shake Shack. With its location just a short walk from the square, this NYC-born burger chain continues to impress. Shake Shack’s ShackBurger is a delicious option, made with 100% Angus beef, topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, and their famous ShackSauce.

Their shakes, of course, are just as popular, especially the Black & White or Strawberry shake. The creamy, rich consistency is a perfect way to top off your meal, making it a favorite for anyone in need of a quick but satisfying burger and shake fix.

Though Shake Shack has expanded globally, there’s something special about experiencing it in New York City, especially near Herald Square. The iconic taste and consistently high quality ensure that it remains a beloved spot in NYC’s fast-food scene.

3. Five Guys: Customization at Its Best

If customization is your thing, Five Guys is another excellent option near Herald Square. Known for its freshly made burgers and hand-cut fries, Five Guys lets you create your perfect burger with a wide variety of toppings to choose from, including grilled onions, mushrooms, and jalapeños.

While they may not be as known for their shakes as other places, their vanilla-based milkshakes are definitely worth trying, especially since you can add mix-ins like chocolate, strawberries, or Oreo pieces. The flexibility in creating your burger and shake combination makes this a favorite for those who like to get creative with their meals.

4. Melt Shop: Grilled Cheese and More

For something a little different, Melt Shop near Herald Square offers up a delightful mix of comfort food, with their Truffle Melt and Shop Tots stealing the spotlight. While not strictly a burger joint, their Fried Chicken Sandwich has earned a loyal following and is often mentioned in the same breath as more traditional burgers.

Pair your sandwich with one of their hand-spun shakes, and you’ve got a meal that rivals any burger joint. Their Nutella shake is a particular favorite, offering a sweet, nutty flavor that pairs well with their savory sandwiches.

5. Friedman’s: A Health-Conscious Option

For those looking for healthier alternatives, Friedman’s is an excellent option, located just steps from Herald Square. Known for their gluten-free menu, Friedman’s offers a selection of burgers that cater to various dietary preferences. Their Classic Grass-Fed Burger is a crowd-pleaser, served with tomato, lettuce, and a side of fries or salad.

Though they focus more on fresh, organic ingredients, you can still indulge in a rich milkshake or a healthier smoothie option to satisfy your sweet tooth. Friedman’s proves that you don’t have to sacrifice taste for health, making it a great choice for those mindful of their diet.

More than Just Food

Herald Square dining isn’t just about satisfying hunger—it’s also about the atmosphere and the overall experience. Whether you’re visiting New York City for the first time or you’re a long-time resident, the area’s bustling vibe adds to the dining experience. With sidewalk seating options at many eateries, you can people-watch and take in the lively energy of Midtown Manhattan while enjoying your meal.

Local Insights: When and Where to Dine

If you’re planning to grab a meal in Herald Square, timing is everything. Weekdays, particularly around lunch hour, can get crowded with office workers and tourists looking for a quick bite. If you want to avoid the rush, consider visiting during off-peak hours, such as early afternoon or late evening.

Additionally, many of the burger spots mentioned offer delivery or takeout, so if you’re in a hurry or want to enjoy your food at a nearby park like Bryant Park, you have plenty of options to choose from.

Conclusion: The Best of Both Worlds

From gourmet burgers to decadent shakes, Herald Square is home to some of the best casual dining spots in Manhattan. Whether you’re looking for a quick meal or a place to sit down and savor every bite, you’ll find plenty of choices that cater to all tastes and preferences.

For burger lovers and shake enthusiasts alike, Herald Square’s diverse culinary offerings provide a well-rounded experience that reflects the vibrancy of New York City’s dining scene. Next time you’re in the area, make sure to try out some of the must-visit spots for the ultimate burgers to shakes in Herald Square  experience.